Merge pull request #248 from jcastillo-arm/jc/tf-issues/212_1

Allow BL3-2 to be loaded into the secure region of DRAM

Makefile

@@ -363,7 +363,7 @@ $(eval PREREQUISITES := $(1).d)
 
 $(1) : $(2)
 	@echo "  PP      $$<"
-	$$(Q)$$(AS) $$(ASFLAGS) -P -E -o $$@ $$<
+	$$(Q)$$(AS) $$(ASFLAGS) -P -E -D__LINKER__ -o $$@ $$<
 
 $(PREREQUISITES) : $(2)
 	@echo "  DEPS    $$@"

docs/firmware-design.md

@@ -1269,14 +1269,19 @@ The following list describes the memory layout on the FVP:
 
 *   BL2 is loaded below BL3-1.
 
-*   The TSP is loaded as the BL3-2 image at the base of either the Trusted
+*   BL3-2 can be loaded in one of the following locations:
-    SRAM or Trusted DRAM. When loaded into Trusted SRAM, its NOBITS sections
-    are allowed to overlay BL2.
 
-This memory layout is designed to give the BL3-2 image as much memory as
+    *   Trusted SRAM
-possible when it is loaded into Trusted SRAM. Depending on the location of the
+    *   Trusted DRAM
-TSP, it will result in different memory maps, illustrated by the following
+    *   Secure region of DRAM (top 16MB of DRAM configured by the TrustZone
-diagrams.
+        controller)
+
+When BL3-2 is loaded into Trusted SRAM, its NOBITS sections are allowed to
+overlay BL2. This memory layout is designed to give the BL3-2 image as much
+memory as possible when it is loaded into Trusted SRAM.
+
+The location of the BL3-2 image will result in different memory maps. This is
+illustrated in the following diagrams using the TSP as an example.
 
 **TSP in Trusted SRAM (default option):**
 
@@ -1324,8 +1329,37 @@ diagrams.
                | BL1 (ro) |
     0x00000000 +----------+
 
-Loading the TSP image in Trusted DRAM doesn't change the memory layout of the
+**TSP in the TZC-Secured DRAM:**
-other boot loader images in Trusted SRAM.
+
+                   DRAM
+    0xffffffff +----------+
+               |  BL3-2   |  (secure)
+    0xff000000 +----------+
+               |          |
+               :          :  (non-secure)
+               |          |
+    0x80000000 +----------+
+
+               Trusted SRAM
+    0x04040000 +----------+  loaded by BL2  ------------------
+               | BL1 (rw) |  <<<<<<<<<<<<<  |  BL3-1 NOBITS  |
+               |----------|  <<<<<<<<<<<<<  |----------------|
+               |          |  <<<<<<<<<<<<<  | BL3-1 PROGBITS |
+               |----------|                 ------------------
+               |   BL2    |
+               |----------|
+               |          |
+    0x04001000 +----------+
+               |  Shared  |
+    0x04000000 +----------+
+
+               Trusted ROM
+    0x04000000 +----------+
+               | BL1 (ro) |
+    0x00000000 +----------+
+
+Moving the TSP image out of the Trusted SRAM doesn't change the memory layout
+of the other boot loader images in Trusted SRAM.
 
 
 ####  Memory layout on Juno ARM development platform

docs/user-guide.md

@@ -259,8 +259,9 @@ performed.
 #### FVP specific build options
 
 *   `FVP_TSP_RAM_LOCATION`: location of the TSP binary. Options:
-    -   `tsram` (default) : Trusted SRAM
+    -   `tsram` : Trusted SRAM (default option)
     -   `tdram` : Trusted DRAM
+    -   `dram`  : Secure region in DRAM (configured by the TrustZone controller)
 
 For a better understanding of FVP options, the FVP memory map is explained in
 the [Firmware Design].

plat/fvp/aarch64/fvp_common.c

@@ -66,8 +66,8 @@ plat_config_t plat_config;
 					DEVICE1_SIZE,			\
 					MT_DEVICE | MT_RW | MT_SECURE)
 
-#define MAP_DRAM1	MAP_REGION_FLAT(DRAM1_BASE,			\
+#define MAP_DRAM1_NS	MAP_REGION_FLAT(DRAM1_NS_BASE,			\
-					DRAM1_SIZE,			\
+					DRAM1_NS_SIZE,			\
 					MT_MEMORY | MT_RW | MT_NS)
 
 #define MAP_TSP_SEC_MEM	MAP_REGION_FLAT(TSP_SEC_MEM_BASE,		\
@@ -94,7 +94,7 @@ const mmap_region_t fvp_mmap[] = {
 	MAP_FLASH0,
 	MAP_DEVICE0,
 	MAP_DEVICE1,
-	MAP_DRAM1,
+	MAP_DRAM1_NS,
 	MAP_TSP_SEC_MEM,
 	{0}
 };

plat/fvp/bl2_fvp_setup.c

@@ -284,8 +284,8 @@ void bl2_plat_get_bl32_meminfo(meminfo_t *bl32_meminfo)
  ******************************************************************************/
 void bl2_plat_get_bl33_meminfo(meminfo_t *bl33_meminfo)
 {
-	bl33_meminfo->total_base = DRAM_BASE;
+	bl33_meminfo->total_base = DRAM1_NS_BASE;
-	bl33_meminfo->total_size = DRAM_SIZE - DRAM1_SEC_SIZE;
+	bl33_meminfo->total_size = DRAM1_NS_SIZE;
-	bl33_meminfo->free_base = DRAM_BASE;
+	bl33_meminfo->free_base = DRAM1_NS_BASE;
-	bl33_meminfo->free_size = DRAM_SIZE - DRAM1_SEC_SIZE;
+	bl33_meminfo->free_size = DRAM1_NS_SIZE;
 }

plat/fvp/fvp_def.h

@@ -36,8 +36,29 @@
 #define FVP_PRIMARY_CPU			0x0
 
 /* Memory location options for TSP */
-#define FVP_IN_TRUSTED_SRAM		0
+#define FVP_TRUSTED_SRAM_ID		0
-#define FVP_IN_TRUSTED_DRAM		1
+#define FVP_TRUSTED_DRAM_ID		1
+#define FVP_DRAM_ID			2
+
+/*
+ * Some of the definitions in this file use the 'ull' suffix in order to avoid
+ * subtle integer overflow errors due to implicit integer type promotion when
+ * working with 32-bit values.
+ *
+ * The TSP linker script includes some of these definitions to define the BL3-2
+ * memory map, but the GNU LD does not support the 'ull' suffix, causing the
+ * build process to fail. To solve this problem, the auxiliary macro MAKE_ULL(x)
+ * will add the 'ull' suffix only when the macro __LINKER__  is not defined
+ * (__LINKER__ is defined in the command line to preprocess the linker script).
+ * Constants in the linker script will not have the 'ull' suffix, but this is
+ * not a problem since the linker evaluates all constant expressions to 64 bit
+ * (assuming the target architecture is 64 bit).
+ */
+#ifndef __LINKER__
+  #define MAKE_ULL(x)			x##ull
+#else
+  #define MAKE_ULL(x)			x
+#endif
 
 /*******************************************************************************
  * FVP memory map related constants
@@ -79,16 +100,24 @@
 #define NSRAM_BASE		0x2e000000
 #define NSRAM_SIZE		0x10000
 
-#define DRAM1_BASE		0x80000000ull
+#define DRAM1_BASE		MAKE_ULL(0x80000000)
-#define DRAM1_SIZE		0x80000000ull
+#define DRAM1_SIZE		MAKE_ULL(0x80000000)
 #define DRAM1_END		(DRAM1_BASE + DRAM1_SIZE - 1)
-#define DRAM1_SEC_SIZE		0x01000000ull
+
+/* Define the top 16 MB of DRAM1 as secure */
+#define DRAM1_SEC_SIZE		MAKE_ULL(0x01000000)
+#define DRAM1_SEC_BASE		(DRAM1_BASE + DRAM1_SIZE - DRAM1_SEC_SIZE)
+#define DRAM1_SEC_END		(DRAM1_SEC_BASE + DRAM1_SEC_SIZE - 1)
+
+#define DRAM1_NS_BASE		DRAM1_BASE
+#define DRAM1_NS_SIZE		(DRAM1_SIZE - DRAM1_SEC_SIZE)
+#define DRAM1_NS_END		(DRAM1_NS_BASE + DRAM1_NS_SIZE - 1)
 
 #define DRAM_BASE		DRAM1_BASE
 #define DRAM_SIZE		DRAM1_SIZE
 
-#define DRAM2_BASE		0x880000000ull
+#define DRAM2_BASE		MAKE_ULL(0x880000000)
-#define DRAM2_SIZE		0x780000000ull
+#define DRAM2_SIZE		MAKE_ULL(0x780000000)
 #define DRAM2_END		(DRAM2_BASE + DRAM2_SIZE - 1)
 
 #define PCIE_EXP_BASE		0x40000000

plat/fvp/fvp_security.c

@@ -89,16 +89,17 @@ void fvp_security_setup(void)
 	 * Allow only non-secure access to all DRAM to supported devices.
 	 * Give access to the CPUs and Virtio. Some devices
 	 * would normally use the default ID so allow that too. We use
-	 * two regions to cover the blocks of physical memory in the FVPs.
+	 * two regions to cover the blocks of physical memory in the FVPs
+	 * plus one region to reserve some memory as secure.
 	 *
 	 * Software executing in the secure state, such as a secure
 	 * boot-loader, can access the DRAM by using the NS attributes in
 	 * the MMU translation tables and descriptors.
 	 */
 
-	/* Set to cover the first block of DRAM */
+	/* Region 1 set to cover the Non-Secure DRAM */
 	tzc_configure_region(FILTER_SHIFT(0), 1,
-			DRAM1_BASE, DRAM1_END - DRAM1_SEC_SIZE,
+			DRAM1_NS_BASE, DRAM1_NS_END,
 			TZC_REGION_S_NONE,
 			TZC_REGION_ACCESS_RDWR(FVP_NSAID_DEFAULT) |
 			TZC_REGION_ACCESS_RDWR(FVP_NSAID_PCI) |
@@ -106,14 +107,14 @@ void fvp_security_setup(void)
 			TZC_REGION_ACCESS_RDWR(FVP_NSAID_VIRTIO) |
 			TZC_REGION_ACCESS_RDWR(FVP_NSAID_VIRTIO_OLD));
 
-	/* Set to cover the secure reserved region */
+	/* Region 2 set to cover the Secure DRAM */
-	tzc_configure_region(FILTER_SHIFT(0), 3,
+	tzc_configure_region(FILTER_SHIFT(0), 2,
-			(DRAM1_END - DRAM1_SEC_SIZE) + 1 , DRAM1_END,
+			DRAM1_SEC_BASE, DRAM1_SEC_END,
 			TZC_REGION_S_RDWR,
 			0x0);
 
-	/* Set to cover the second block of DRAM */
+	/* Region 3 set to cover the second block of DRAM */
-	tzc_configure_region(FILTER_SHIFT(0), 2,
+	tzc_configure_region(FILTER_SHIFT(0), 3,
 			DRAM2_BASE, DRAM2_END, TZC_REGION_S_NONE,
 			TZC_REGION_ACCESS_RDWR(FVP_NSAID_DEFAULT) |
 			TZC_REGION_ACCESS_RDWR(FVP_NSAID_PCI) |

plat/fvp/include/platform_def.h

@@ -128,19 +128,25 @@
  * BL32 specific defines.
  ******************************************************************************/
 /*
- * On FVP, the TSP can execute either from Trusted SRAM or Trusted DRAM.
+ * On FVP, the TSP can execute from Trusted SRAM, Trusted DRAM or the DRAM
+ * region secured by the TrustZone controller.
  */
-#if FVP_TSP_RAM_LOCATION_ID == FVP_IN_TRUSTED_SRAM
+#if FVP_TSP_RAM_LOCATION_ID == FVP_TRUSTED_SRAM_ID
 # define TSP_SEC_MEM_BASE		FVP_TRUSTED_SRAM_BASE
 # define TSP_SEC_MEM_SIZE		FVP_TRUSTED_SRAM_SIZE
 # define TSP_PROGBITS_LIMIT		BL2_BASE
 # define BL32_BASE			FVP_TRUSTED_SRAM_BASE
 # define BL32_LIMIT			BL31_BASE
-#elif FVP_TSP_RAM_LOCATION_ID == FVP_IN_TRUSTED_DRAM
+#elif FVP_TSP_RAM_LOCATION_ID == FVP_TRUSTED_DRAM_ID
 # define TSP_SEC_MEM_BASE		FVP_TRUSTED_DRAM_BASE
 # define TSP_SEC_MEM_SIZE		FVP_TRUSTED_DRAM_SIZE
 # define BL32_BASE			FVP_TRUSTED_DRAM_BASE
 # define BL32_LIMIT			(FVP_TRUSTED_DRAM_BASE + (1 << 21))
+#elif FVP_TSP_RAM_LOCATION_ID == FVP_DRAM_ID
+# define TSP_SEC_MEM_BASE		DRAM1_SEC_BASE
+# define TSP_SEC_MEM_SIZE		DRAM1_SEC_SIZE
+# define BL32_BASE			DRAM1_SEC_BASE
+# define BL32_LIMIT			(DRAM1_SEC_BASE + DRAM1_SEC_SIZE)
 #else
 # error "Unsupported FVP_TSP_RAM_LOCATION_ID value"
 #endif
@@ -154,7 +160,21 @@
  * Platform specific page table and MMU setup constants
  ******************************************************************************/
 #define ADDR_SPACE_SIZE			(1ull << 32)
-#define MAX_XLAT_TABLES			2
+
+#if IMAGE_BL1
+# define MAX_XLAT_TABLES		2
+#elif IMAGE_BL2
+# define MAX_XLAT_TABLES		3
+#elif IMAGE_BL31
+# define MAX_XLAT_TABLES		2
+#elif IMAGE_BL32
+# if FVP_TSP_RAM_LOCATION_ID == FVP_DRAM_ID
+#  define MAX_XLAT_TABLES		3
+# else
+#  define MAX_XLAT_TABLES		2
+# endif
+#endif
+
 #define MAX_MMAP_REGIONS		16
 
 /*******************************************************************************

plat/fvp/platform.mk

@@ -32,9 +32,11 @@
 # Trusted SRAM is the default.
 FVP_TSP_RAM_LOCATION	:=	tsram
 ifeq (${FVP_TSP_RAM_LOCATION}, tsram)
-  FVP_TSP_RAM_LOCATION_ID := FVP_IN_TRUSTED_SRAM
+  FVP_TSP_RAM_LOCATION_ID := FVP_TRUSTED_SRAM_ID
 else ifeq (${FVP_TSP_RAM_LOCATION}, tdram)
-  FVP_TSP_RAM_LOCATION_ID := FVP_IN_TRUSTED_DRAM
+  FVP_TSP_RAM_LOCATION_ID := FVP_TRUSTED_DRAM_ID
+else ifeq (${FVP_TSP_RAM_LOCATION}, dram)
+  FVP_TSP_RAM_LOCATION_ID := FVP_DRAM_ID
 else
   $(error "Unsupported FVP_TSP_RAM_LOCATION value")
 endif